Survival difference between surgery and non surgery of HCC
Survival Difference between Surgery Versus Non-Surgery for the Treatment
of Hepatocellular Carcinoma Patients at Liver Centre, Malaysia
Azmawati MN 1 , Azmi MT 1
, Krishnan R 2
1Department of Community Health, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Medical Centre, Jalan Yaacob Latif,
Bandar Tun Razak, 56000 Cheras, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
2Department of Hepato-Pancreato-Bialiary, Hospital Selayang, Lebuh Raya Selayang-Kepong, Batu
Caves, 68000 Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia
Abstract
Hepatic resection, the only treatment that offers long term survival for patients with Hepatocellular carcinoma
(HCC), have shown significant improvement in results over the past decades.
The aim of the study was to compare
the survival between patients receiving and not receiving surgery. A retrospective cohort study measured the survival
of newly diagnosed cases of HCC patients who underwent treatment in Selayang Hospital from 1 January 2003 till
31 December 2006.
Survival time was measured from the date of diagnosis until the subjects died or until the end of
study period (31 December 2007).
Overall survival was significantly longer in surgery group in comparison with
non-surgery group with a median survival of 43 and 20 months, respectively (p<0.001).
The following factors were
noted to have improved survival duration with surgical resection; Child Pugh Class B patients, tumor size less or
more than 4cm and number of nodules less than 3.
Subgroup analysis showed improved survival duration with
surgical resection among patients with Child Pugh Class B with tumor size less than 4cm or with nodule less than 3
and patients who had less than 3 nodules, even with tumor size of less or more than 4cm.
Multivariate Cox Regression
showed surgical intervention significantly improved survival time for overall patients (Adjusted HR: 1.5)
while non-surgery improved survival in patients with tumor size less than 4cm (Adjusted HR: 0.4).
Surgical
resection significantly improved the survival duration in overall patients while non-surgical procedure improved
survival if the tumor size was less than 4cm.
Keywords: HCC, surgery, survival, Selayang Hospital, tumor size.
Correspondence:
Dr. Azmawati Mohammed Nawi, Department of Community Health, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Medical Centre, Jalan
Yaakob Latiff, 56000 Cheras, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Tel: +603-91455901 Fax: +6 03-91737825 Email: atienawi@yahoo.com
Date of submission: 25th May 2011
Date of acceptance: 23rd Sept 2011
Date of publication: 03rd Oct 2011
Introduction
Most researchers have found out that Hepatocellular
Carcinoma (HCC) was increasing in trend as well as
the mortality. HCC accounts for 6% of all cancers
worldwide and the fifth commonest cancer in the
world. The estimated number of people who develop
HCC is 564,000 cases per year worldwide (1). In
Malaysia, HCC is one of the commonest malignancies
with an age-standardised annual incidence of 2.8 cases
per 100,000 populations (2). It accounts for 5.6% of all
cancers and 8.1% of all cancer related death in this
country. It is the twelfth commonest cancer in men and
ranked eighteenth amongst women in Malaysia as
reported by National Cancer Registries, 2002 (2).
Hepatic resection, the only treatment that offers longterm
survival for patients with HCC, has shown
significant improvement in results within past decade
(3-6). Although few would contest this wellOriginal
Research Article
Survival difference between surgery and non surgery of HCC Azmawati MN et al.
11
established fact, the paradox is that no randomized
study has clearly demonstrated the benefit of surgery
especially in liver centre of Malaysia, Selayang
Hospital. HCC is often associated with cirrhosis and
the remnant hepatic functional reserve is not always
preserved well and candidates for hepatic resection are
limited (7-9). Recently, HCC have been often treated
by nonsurgical therapeutic options such as transhepatic
arterial chemoembolization (TACE), percutaneous
ethanol injection treatment (PEI) (10), microwave
coagulation therapy (MCT) (11) and percutaneous
radiofrequency thermal ablation (RFA) (12).
The reported 5-year overall survival for surgery ranges
from 35% to 60%, whereas the 3-year overall survival
for non-surgery ranges from 13% to 26% (13-14). In
view of that, we opine that surgery gives better survival
for HCC patients compared to non-surgery. This study
aims to give evidence based benefit of surgery in HCC
patients at the liver centre of Malaysia with regard to
survival. It is hypothesized that surgery gives a better
survival compared to non-surgery procedures.
METHODS
Study Design
Selayang Hospital is known as liver centre of Malaysia
in which start operated on 2000. Most of hepatobiliary
disease was referred here for further management as
well as HCC. This study was a retrospective cohort to
all newly diagnosed HCC patients by CT Scan in liver
centre, Malaysia (Selayang Hospital) from 1 January
2003 till 31 December 2006. All patients were
followed up until achieving the primary endpoint
(death) or until the end of the study as on 31 December
2007. It was universal sampling with inclusion and
exclusion criteria being constructed. Inclusion criteria
were based on all newly diagnosed HCC patients with
CT Scan from 1 January 2003 till 31 December 2006
and exclusion criteria included multiple cancer.
Sample size of 210 was based on study by Verhoef et
al (15) with power of 90%. Demographic information
(age, gender, ethnic, alcohol intake, hepatitis status)
and clinical variables (tumor size, number of nodules,
Child Pugh Class, types of treatment) were obtained
from medical records. The surgeon decided on the type
of treatment that depended on findings of CT Scan in
which this study only focussed on tumor size, number
of nodules and Child Pugh Class. Small tumor, less
nodules involved with Child Pugh class A or early B
were considered as candidate for surgical resection.
Data was collected between February to April 2009 by
review all the variables in medical record. The CT
Scan finding was noted in view of tumor size and
number of nodules involved. All the patients were
followed up for their survival status by registering
death and via telephone.
Statistical Analysis
All data were collected and analyzed with statistical
computer software (SPSS 13.0). Categorical variables
were compared using the chi-square test and overall
survival analyses were carried out using the KaplanMeier
methods. Comparisons between different groups
were carried out using log rank test. Multivariate
analyses for survival were carried out using Cox’s
Regression model. Tests were deemed to be significant
at the 0.05 levels. The survival status coded as death
(1) and censored (0).
RESULTS
Demographic
A total of 210 HCC patients were evaluated from 1
January 2003 till 31 December 2006 with 123 patients
dead and 87 being censored case. Most of HCC patients
were aged between 40-60 years, males, Chinese ethnic,
with no alcohol intake and positive hepatitis status as
shown in Table 1. Out of 210 HCC patients, 114
patients underwent surgical resection and 96 patients
received non-surgical procedure. The choice of surgery
significantly depended on age group and alcohol status.
Majority of HCC patients were Child Pugh Class A in
which 65.6% underwent surgical resection while Child
Pugh Class B and Child Pugh Class C were mostly
received non-surgery procedures. The difference was
significant as well as in number of nodules involved. As
shown in Table 2, most of HCC patients who underwent
surgical resection involved nodules less than 3(59%)
compared to only 36.4% patients with nodules more
than 3. Out of 210 patients, 128 patients presented with
tumor size more than 4cm with 59.4% were having
surgical resection. However, only 46.3% of tumor size
less than 3cm underwent surgical resection.
Survival
Overall median survival time for patients having
surgical resection was 43 months (95%CI: 31.7-54.3)
with a 3-year and 5-year survival rate of 55% and 26%,
respectively. It showed that surgery had a better survival
compared to non-surgical procedures in which overall
median survival time was only 20 months (95%CI:
15.5-24.4) with a 3-year and 5-year survival rate of only
23% and 13%, respectively (Table 3, Figure 1).
Survival difference between surgery and non surgery of HCC Azmawati MN et al.
12
Table 1: Demographic of HCC patients
Variables Total (n=210)
Had Surgery
p value
Yes (n=114) No (n=96)
Age
<40 years old 14(6.7%) 12(85.7%) 2(14.3)
40-60 years old 112(53.3%) 54(48.2%) 58(51.8%) 0.02
>60 years old 84(40.0%) 48(57.1%) 36(42.9%)
Gender
Male 166(79%) 86(51.8%) 80(48.2%)
0.16
Female 44(21%) 28(63.6%) 16(36.4%)
Ethnic
Chinese 159(75.7%) 87(54.7%) 72(45.3%)
Malay 42(20%) 23(54.8%) 19(45.2%) 0.83
Indian 9(4.3%) 4(44.4%) 5(55.6%)
Alcohol
No 124(59%) 75(60.5) 49(39.5)
0.03
Yes 86(41%) 39(45.3) 47(54.7)
Hepatitis Status
No 49(19%) 25(62.5) 15(37.5)
0.25
Yes 170(81%) 89(52.4) 81(47.6)
Table 2: Clinical variables of HCC patients
Variables Total (n=210)
Had Surgery
p value
Yes (n=114) No(n=96)
Child Pugh
Class
A 125(59.5%) 82(65.6%) 43(34.4%)
B 80(38.1%) 32(40%) 48(60%) <0.001
C 5(2.4%) 0 5(100%)
Tumor Size
<4cm 82(39%) 38(46.3%) 44(53.7%)
0.064
>4cm 128(61%) 76(59.4%) 52(40.6%)
Number of nodules
<3 166(79%) 98(59%) 68(41%)
0.007
>3 44(21%) 16(36.4%) 28(63.6%)
Table 3 summarized the differences between HCC
patients who underwent surgical resection or not with
clinical variables which played an important factor
especially before deciding the types of treatment. For
the surgery group, the median survival time was better
with Child Pugh Class B (25 months, 95% CI: 5.8-
44.2), tumor size less than 4cm (57 months, 95% CI:
44.4-69.6), tumor size more than 4cm (21 months,
Survival difference between surgery and non surgery of HCC Azmawati MN et al.
13
Table 3: Univariate Analysis of Survival
Figure 1: Kaplan-Meier survival estimates by treatment
Variables n Died Median(months) 95%CI 1
year
3
year
5
year
p value
Overall
Surgery 114 54 43 31.7-54.3 74 55 26
<0.0001
No Surgery 96 69 20 15.5-24.4 61 23 13
Child Pugh Class A
Surgery 82 34 57 39.2-74.7 75 61 35
0.22
No Surgery 43 22 26 19.9-32.0 86 37 37
Child Pugh Class B
Surgery 32 20 25 5.8-44.2 65 47 23
0.04
No Surgery 48 42 13 10.1-15.9 76 14 0.4
HCC <4cm
Surgery 37 11 57 44.4-69.6 88 84 30
0.003
No Surgery 41 24 25 17.7-32.3 73 38 25
HCC >4cm
Surgery 77 43 21 11.4-30.6 66 39 24
0.005
No Surgery 55 45 15 9.6-18.3 48 0.7 0.7
Nodule <3
Surgery 98 40 57 38.9-75.1 76 62 34
<0.005
No Surgery 68 46 21 15.1-26.8 69 27 13
Nodule >3
Surgery 16 14 12 2.5-21.5 56 19
0.632
No Surgery 28 23 12 9.5-14.5 60 15 13
Survival difference between surgery and non surgery of HCC Azmawati
For full report see:
http://jsurgacad.com/sites/default/files/article/2012/Survival%20difference%20between%20surgery%20and%20non%20surgery%20of%20HCC.pdf
Showing posts with label Selayang Hospital. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Selayang Hospital. Show all posts
Friday, 9 December 2016
Wednesday, 23 November 2011
Selayang Hospital - Liver Cancer Treatment, KL
The hepatobiliary unit at the Hospital Selayang, which is now the national tertiary referral centre for liver diseases, receives about 150 patients with liver cancer every year. Beware liver cancer!
Sunday December 12, 2010
This post is on Healthwise

That means, when you show up at your doctor’s office with symptoms like a bloated abdomen, jaundice, drastic weight loss, and a feeling of heaviness in your upper abdomen, even though there may be treatments to get the cancer under control, your chances of a cure might be limited.
Unfortunately, in Malaysia, this is the norm rather than the exception.
“Patients still come late to us,” says Mr R. Krishnan, head of hepatobiliary surgery at Hospital Selayang. The unit, which is now the national tertiary referral centre for liver diseases, receives about 150 patients with liver cancer every year.
“Right now, for the bulk of our patients, there is little we could offer,” says Mr Krishnan. It’s only in less than 25% of cases that we could offer some sort of treatment for their cancer,” he notes.
However, hope is not lost. Liver cancer might be a silent disease, but its risk factors and causes are rather well documented. The trick is to minimise your risk factors, monitor your liver regularly if you have any of the conditions that may lead to liver cancer, and follow the timeless health advice: live a healthy lifestyle.
Know the causes and risk factors
While more recent data is yet to be published, going by the numbers provided in the National Cancer Registry in 2006, liver cancer was then already ranked the sixth most common cancer among Malaysians. It was the fifth most common cancer among males and ninth most common cancer among females in Peninsular Malaysia.
There are two types of liver cancer. Cancers of the liver caused by malignant changes in liver cells are called primary liver cancers (hepatocellular carcinoma). Cancers in the liver that are caused by the spread and retention of cancer cells from elsewhere are called secondary liver cancers.
“Most of the time, (primary) liver cancer occurs in people with some underlying liver problem,” says Ministry of Health national head of surgical services Datuk Mr Harjit Singh, who is also former head of hepatobiliary surgery at Hospital Selayang.
A lot of them have hepatitis B or C infections, alcoholic liver disease, fatty liver, or any kind of liver disease that can lead to cirrhosis (the formation of scar tissue in the liver). However, the problem is that most people take these things for granted.
“They don’t go for any form of check-ups or screening tests,” says Mr Harjit. “By the time they present with pain or symptoms, the disease is already (at) an advanced (stage).”
According to a consensus paper on the management of hepatocellular carcinoma (primary liver cancer) in Asia that Mr Harjit co-authored, the risk factors for developing liver cancer in Asia include heavy exposure to aflatoxin (toxins produced by a type of fungus), algal hepatotoxins (liver toxins) in contaminated water, betel nut chewing, diabetes mellitus, and alcohol abuse leading to liver cirrhosis.
However, the main known cause for liver cancer in Asia is chronic hepatitis B virus infection. “In Malaysia, it is hepatitis B. But (liver cancer due to) hepatitis C is picking up,” says Mr Krishnan.
That said, these remain as risk factors. There is no guarantee that you will develop liver cancer if you have these conditions. Nevertheless, you have a greater chance of developing it compared to those who don’t.
Care, monitor, and don’t work it too hard
So, how do you prevent liver cancer? You can start by taking steps to prevent or minimise the risk factors and have your liver checked if you have any underlying liver disease.
Getting yourself immunised against hepatitis B is a start. Malaysians who are born after 1989 would have already been immunised as a child under the National Immunisation Schedule, but those born before that will have to obtain their immunisation from their local healthcare providers. There is still no vaccine for hepatitis C.
As both viruses are transmitted through the exposure to infectious blood or body fluids, avoiding and managing situations that may lead to its transmission – like unprotected sex, needle sharing, and transmission from mother to child during delivery – can help prevent one from getting infected.
That is why even for procedures that involve needles like tattoo drawings, body piercings, and even acupuncture, it is important to make sure that the needles used are disposable ones meant for single use, Mr Harjit explains.
Pregnant mothers with hepatitis B can also be given appropriate treatment to prevent the child from being infected as well.
On top of that, those with a family history of liver disease or liver cancer should also get themselves screened regularly through medical checkups.
People who have underlying liver disease must, essentially, follow up with their family physician or their regular GP and get their screening tests done at least every six months, says Mr Harjit.
Even people who are healthy should at least get themselves tested for diseases such as hepatitis B and C, especially when they have reached the age of 30.
“We have almost 2.5 million hepatitis B carriers in this country. A significant proportion of them are at a risk of developing chronic liver disease,” Mr Harjit adds.
A healthy diet and regular exercise also plays a role in preventing liver cancer as well. At the very least, it could minimise one of the risk factors – fatty liver – that is usually associated with excessive consumption of alcohol and the metabolic syndrome (brought about by unhealthy diets and physical inactivity). This will, in turn, minimise your risk of developing liver cancer.
Work with your regular doctors
As the hepatobiliary unit in Hospital Selayang is a tertiary care centre, the patients they receive are mostly referrals from primary care doctors. But both Mr Krishnan and Datuk Mr Harjit emphasises that you don’t have to go to a liver specialist for a normal checkup.
“Ideally, the message is that people should be seen by their primary care doctors,” says Mr Harjit. “If their doctors find any liver problems, like liver masses or tumours, they can refer the patients to us,” he adds.
Source:
http://www.thestar.com.my/lifestyle/health/2010/12/12/stand-and-deliver/
http://thestar.com.my/health/story.asp?file=/2010/12/12/health/7599479&sec=health
Article added on 16 October 2014:
Updated: Friday November 8, 2013 MYT 4:16:29 PM
Article added on 9 December 2016:
Others articles:
Sunday December 12, 2010
This post is on Healthwise
Stand and de-liver
TO a large extent, liver cancer is a silent disease. And when signs and symptoms appear, it may be too late for doctors to offer any form of curative treatment for the cancer.That means, when you show up at your doctor’s office with symptoms like a bloated abdomen, jaundice, drastic weight loss, and a feeling of heaviness in your upper abdomen, even though there may be treatments to get the cancer under control, your chances of a cure might be limited.
| Since its relocation to Hospital Selayang in 1999, the hepatobiliary unit has evolved into a national tertiary referral centre specialised in the management of critically ill patients with acute and chronic liver diseases. |
| Mr R. Krishnan ... Patients still come late to us. |
| Datuk Mr Harjit Singh ... Most of the time, primary liver cancer occurs in people with some underlying liver disease |
Unfortunately, in Malaysia, this is the norm rather than the exception.
“Patients still come late to us,” says Mr R. Krishnan, head of hepatobiliary surgery at Hospital Selayang. The unit, which is now the national tertiary referral centre for liver diseases, receives about 150 patients with liver cancer every year.
“Right now, for the bulk of our patients, there is little we could offer,” says Mr Krishnan. It’s only in less than 25% of cases that we could offer some sort of treatment for their cancer,” he notes.
However, hope is not lost. Liver cancer might be a silent disease, but its risk factors and causes are rather well documented. The trick is to minimise your risk factors, monitor your liver regularly if you have any of the conditions that may lead to liver cancer, and follow the timeless health advice: live a healthy lifestyle.
Know the causes and risk factors
While more recent data is yet to be published, going by the numbers provided in the National Cancer Registry in 2006, liver cancer was then already ranked the sixth most common cancer among Malaysians. It was the fifth most common cancer among males and ninth most common cancer among females in Peninsular Malaysia.
There are two types of liver cancer. Cancers of the liver caused by malignant changes in liver cells are called primary liver cancers (hepatocellular carcinoma). Cancers in the liver that are caused by the spread and retention of cancer cells from elsewhere are called secondary liver cancers.
“Most of the time, (primary) liver cancer occurs in people with some underlying liver problem,” says Ministry of Health national head of surgical services Datuk Mr Harjit Singh, who is also former head of hepatobiliary surgery at Hospital Selayang.
A lot of them have hepatitis B or C infections, alcoholic liver disease, fatty liver, or any kind of liver disease that can lead to cirrhosis (the formation of scar tissue in the liver). However, the problem is that most people take these things for granted.
“They don’t go for any form of check-ups or screening tests,” says Mr Harjit. “By the time they present with pain or symptoms, the disease is already (at) an advanced (stage).”
According to a consensus paper on the management of hepatocellular carcinoma (primary liver cancer) in Asia that Mr Harjit co-authored, the risk factors for developing liver cancer in Asia include heavy exposure to aflatoxin (toxins produced by a type of fungus), algal hepatotoxins (liver toxins) in contaminated water, betel nut chewing, diabetes mellitus, and alcohol abuse leading to liver cirrhosis.
However, the main known cause for liver cancer in Asia is chronic hepatitis B virus infection. “In Malaysia, it is hepatitis B. But (liver cancer due to) hepatitis C is picking up,” says Mr Krishnan.
That said, these remain as risk factors. There is no guarantee that you will develop liver cancer if you have these conditions. Nevertheless, you have a greater chance of developing it compared to those who don’t.
Care, monitor, and don’t work it too hard
So, how do you prevent liver cancer? You can start by taking steps to prevent or minimise the risk factors and have your liver checked if you have any underlying liver disease.
Getting yourself immunised against hepatitis B is a start. Malaysians who are born after 1989 would have already been immunised as a child under the National Immunisation Schedule, but those born before that will have to obtain their immunisation from their local healthcare providers. There is still no vaccine for hepatitis C.
As both viruses are transmitted through the exposure to infectious blood or body fluids, avoiding and managing situations that may lead to its transmission – like unprotected sex, needle sharing, and transmission from mother to child during delivery – can help prevent one from getting infected.
That is why even for procedures that involve needles like tattoo drawings, body piercings, and even acupuncture, it is important to make sure that the needles used are disposable ones meant for single use, Mr Harjit explains.
Pregnant mothers with hepatitis B can also be given appropriate treatment to prevent the child from being infected as well.
On top of that, those with a family history of liver disease or liver cancer should also get themselves screened regularly through medical checkups.
People who have underlying liver disease must, essentially, follow up with their family physician or their regular GP and get their screening tests done at least every six months, says Mr Harjit.
Even people who are healthy should at least get themselves tested for diseases such as hepatitis B and C, especially when they have reached the age of 30.
“We have almost 2.5 million hepatitis B carriers in this country. A significant proportion of them are at a risk of developing chronic liver disease,” Mr Harjit adds.
A healthy diet and regular exercise also plays a role in preventing liver cancer as well. At the very least, it could minimise one of the risk factors – fatty liver – that is usually associated with excessive consumption of alcohol and the metabolic syndrome (brought about by unhealthy diets and physical inactivity). This will, in turn, minimise your risk of developing liver cancer.
Work with your regular doctors
As the hepatobiliary unit in Hospital Selayang is a tertiary care centre, the patients they receive are mostly referrals from primary care doctors. But both Mr Krishnan and Datuk Mr Harjit emphasises that you don’t have to go to a liver specialist for a normal checkup.
“Ideally, the message is that people should be seen by their primary care doctors,” says Mr Harjit. “If their doctors find any liver problems, like liver masses or tumours, they can refer the patients to us,” he adds.
Source:
http://www.thestar.com.my/lifestyle/health/2010/12/12/stand-and-deliver/
http://thestar.com.my/health/story.asp?file=/2010/12/12/health/7599479&sec=health
Article added on 16 October 2014:
Hospital Selayang hepatobiliary unit
Published: Sunday December 12, 2010 MYT 12:00:00 AMUpdated: Friday November 8, 2013 MYT 4:16:29 PM
DEDICATED liver services in Malaysia started only in 1992, and was pioneered by Health Ministry director-general Tan Sri Dr Mohd Ismail Merican in Hospital Kuala Lumpur to meet the demands of patients who suffer from complications of liver diseases.
In 1999, this service was relocated to Hospital Selayang, which has since evolved into the national tertiary referral centre specialised in the management of critically ill patients with acute and chronic liver diseases.
In year 2000, the then head of the Hospital Selayang hepatobilary surgery Datuk Mr Harjit Singh commenced the liver transplant service in the unit. Since then, there have been 45 liver transplants done in the centre, with an overall survival rate of 72%.
“A lot of our patients do not know where to go,” says Dr Ismail, who is also currently the head of the hepatology unit in the centre. “There were attempts to do liver transplantation in private centres, but we felt that liver transplantation should be offered to patients in a public facility ... as it is very specialised and very resource intensive,” he adds. The unit is currently the only centre in Malaysia that performs liver transplants.
Besides offering services for complex liver diseases at the Hospital Selayang hepatobilary unit, the Ministry of Health, together with the Malaysian Liver Foundation, also organises biennial Liver Updates to inform local doctors about the latest findings and technology in liver treatment and diagnostics.
The 9th Liver Update, which will be held next year on July 13 to 17 at the Sunway Lagoon Resort hotel, will feature live surgery workshops and talks by international speakers and is open to all healthcare professionals who are interested in liver care.
As the hepatobiliary unit receives more and more patients, it is the unit’s hope to eventually have a liver centre of its own. “Hopefully, with a dedicated liver centre, we will be able to retain our specialists and ask some of them who have left to come back,” says Dr Ismail. A dedicated liver centre could also help the unit meet the increasing demands of liver services in the country, he adds.
http://www.thestar.com.my/Lifestyle/Health/2010/12/12/Hospital-Selayang-hepatobiliary-unit/Article added on 9 December 2016:
Kudos to Selayang Hospital for superb service
Tuesday, 3 March 2015
OUR father, Mohamed Mokhtar Ahmad Bajunid, was diagnosed with liver and thyroid cancer in December last year.
We can hardly forget that day when the doctors broke the news. We, the children, pooled our resources and tried to offer the best support we could monetarily, physically and emotionally.
We immediately thought of a private hospital or at least a semi-government one where we believed our dad would receive the best treatment.
When we were told to take our father to Selayang Hospital, we were apprehensive in the beginning.
We’ve read many news reports about misdiagnosis and low standard of service and care in government facilities.
We were clearly prejudiced on the onset. We proceeded to the hospital with caution and were ready to jump ship at any time and shoot off to other perceived “better” hospitals.
Little did we know this arduous journey would lift the veil of misconception that had been drummed into us for a long time.
It began with a meeting with Dr T. Haritharan, the hepatobiliary specialist and surgeon. He sat with dad and took his time explaining then answering questions, not forgetting to repeat where needed.
His patience and understanding were exemplary. We shamelessly voiced our concerns about the hospital and asked if dad could be referred elsewhere to which he answered with an affirmative.
Yet, he went on to explain that most specialists they may refer us to were also trained at Selayang Hospital by the very doctors currently practising there.
He assured dad he was in good hands and there was no need to look elsewhere. They would also bring in a specialist, Dr Sarinah Basro, from Putrajaya Hospital to oversee his thyroid cancer.
All this were expressed without any display of drama or ego. It was laid out to us calmly, precisely and in simple terms.
We went home and did our research and found out repeatedly that Selayang Hospital was touted as the best facility for liver and abdominal cancer. We decided to forge ahead based on all the positive reviews. It was no exaggeration.
From the moment dad checked in, through his surgery to his last day in the hospital, he received gracious attention from the nurses, attentive care from the doctors and timely and professional treatment from the specialists.
Even in my father’s most depressed state, an emotion many will face in these type of situations, the doctors, notably Dr Haritharan, treated him – the person – not just the illness.
These doctors are highly respected by their peers and set a strong example for others to follow.
We commend them for their outstanding achievements and exemplary service. Others should emulate their commendable dedicated service.
Our mother, Sirima Binthep, never left his side and was equally treated with kindness and respect by the hospital staff, from the security personnel right up to the doctors.
They seemed to know a little smile and kindly spoken words would go a long way to ease the burdened soul.
Today, with God’s grace, our father has been declared cancer free, just a little more than a month after his surgery.
Though we can finally breathe a sigh of relief, our thoughts and prayers are with those still battling this horrendous disease.
We would also like to thank the entire staff of Selayang Hospital. Thank you Dr Haritharan, Dr Yang Khuan Fatt, Dr Tee Chee Sian, Datuk Dr Harjit Singh, Dr R. Krishnan, Dr Suryati Mokhtar, Dr Lim Kin Foong and the nurses of ward 9B, and Putrajaya Hospital’s Dr Sarinah.
Whatever the future brings, to you we owe our eternal gratitude.
AZHAR SYARAWI
SARINA MOKHTAR
SUVANI MOKHTAR
AZLAN SYARAWI
(Children of Mohamed Mokhtar Ahmad Bajunid)
http://www.thestar.com.my/opinion/letters/2015/03/03/kudos-to-selayang-hospital-for-superb-service/Others articles:
- Liver Cancer
- Liver Cancer and Coffee
- Fat livers
- Fatty liver may be the next major health woe
- De-liver me from illness
- Selayang Hospital - Liver Cancer Treatment, KL
- Survival Difference between Surgery and Non-Surgery for the Treatment of Hepatocellular Carcinoma Patients at Liver Centre, Malaysia
- Treating liver cancer
- Kidney & Liver Cancer - Treatment options
- Rogue stem cells in liver cancer
- Stem Cell treatment for Liver Cancer
Also:
http://healthticket.blogspot.my/2016/03/foreign-patients-turn-to-india-in.html
Added on 09 December 2016:
http://epjjmedimagingselayang.blogspot.my/p/imaging-department.html
Added on 31 December 2016:
Added on 09 December 2016:
Radiology Department Selayang Hospital
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
International Perspective Selayang Hospital: A Paperless and Filmless ...
by H Rosnah - 2004 - Related articles
Selayang Hospital has set a milestone in Malaysian history for being the first hospital in the country to create a “paperless and filmless” environment for its ...Added on 31 December 2016:
Survival Difference between Surgery and Non-Surgery for the Treatment of Hepatocellular Carcinoma Patients at Liver Centre, Malaysia
Labels:
Cancer - Liver,
Hepatitis B,
Hepatitis C,
Liver health,
Malaysia,
Selayang Hospital,
The Star
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)